What smart people are saying about the 2 most controversial parts of Anthropic's new models

David Kasten said he believes Anthropic is genuinely trying to reduce the risks associated with Mythos.

"I do very much take Anthropic at their word that they are trying hard to de-risk what they see as the two risky features of Mythos," Kasten told Business Insider.

Still, Kasten said releasing the model carries risk because "it's always a bit of a cat-and-mouse game between attacker and defender."

Kasten added that Anthropic likely sees itself in a race with rival AI labs that may soon have similarly powerful models.

"For them, I think there's a little bit of a, how much of their lead in the race do they think they can afford to burn?" he said.

Davi Ottenheimer, a prominent digital safety expert, questioned whether Mythos was ever as dangerous as Anthropic suggested.

"Anthropic marketing said in April that Mythos was too dangerous to be in public hands," Ottenheimer told Business Insider. "And yet today they are selling it, unchanged, to the public."

Mythos was withheld from public release in April after Anthropic warned that the model was so capable at finding cybersecurity flaws that it posed safety risks.

"They're using security as a marketing trick," Ottenheimer added.

Roman Stanek said that AI capability isn't the real problem in cybersecurity.

"The thing with AI and cybersecurity is that the vulnerabilities we're worried about AI exploiting, well we've known about most of them for 20 years," Stanek said in a note sent to Business Insider. "We just never fixed them."

"Nobody wanted to pay a human engineer to fix it," he added. "They're not going to pay an AI to fix it either."

Elie Bakouch criticized Anthropic's decision to intentionally limit Mythos' performance on certain AI development tasks.

"Mythos will be bad ON PURPOSE on AI 'frontier LLM research' tasks," Bakouch wrote on X on Tuesday. "This is very very sad for the research community."

Bakouch also called it "crazy" that the intervention would not be visible to users.

Jeremy Howard said that Anthropic's safeguards could increase concentration in the AI industry.

"Anthropic has chosen the opposite of the safe path," Howard wrote in an X post on Wednesday. "They are allowing themselves, the current top lab, to use their top model for frontier AI research."

Howard said the result is that "the AI frontier advances, & power imbalance increases."

Patrick Moorhead said his first experience with Fable 5 left him underwhelmed.

In a post on X on Wednesday, Moorhead said the model refused to help with earnings-analysis talking points and a board presentation because Fable 5 deemed the tasks "too dangerous."

"Is this the model we're all frightened of and makes Anthropic worth $1T?" he wrote. "Okedokee."

Gergely Orosz said Anthropic's safeguards could end up affecting people who aren't actually building competing AI models.

"Anthropic assumes SemiAnalysis is developing a competing LLM and so it dumbs down their model for them," Orosz wrote on X on Wednesday.

"Anthropic trying to limit competition limits many others," he added.

Deedy Das focused on the model's capabilities rather than its safeguards.

"Claude Fable 5 is by far the most ridiculous model that makes me genuinely afraid for the future of software engineering," Das wrote in an X post on Wednesday.

Das pointed to examples including migrating a 50 million-line codebase, generating advanced 3D graphics, and outperforming rival models on optimization tasks.

He also said that Fable 5 is about the same price as OpenAI's GPT-5.5 and six times cheaper than GPT-5.5 Pro.

Thibault is a business reporter at Business Insider's London office.He covers the intersection of wealth, work, and technology — focusing on the global economy, AI’s impact on the workplace, job and cognitive skills, and how economic changes are affecting careers. Before moving to the trending team, Thibault covered international affairs, including the Russia-Ukraine war, tensions in the South China Sea, and Russia’s economy on the news desk.He has previously worked at the Daily Express and held internships at Agence France-Presse, Politico Europe, and Factal.Il parle français. Se habla español.Email Thibault at [email protected], connect with him on LinkedIn @ThibaultSpirlet, or follow him on X @ThibaultSpirlet and BlueSky @thibaultspirlet.bsky.social.Expertise

• AI and the future of work 
• Job and cognitive skills in the AI economy
• Workforce trends
• First-person, "as-told-to" business stories

Popular articles

• AI isn't making us smarter — it's training us to think backward, an innovation theorist says
• Netflix tried full pay transparency for senior staff — it ended up fueling petty rivalries, Reed Hastings says
• Duolingo gives staff 2 weeks off over the holidays — and the CEO says it pays off
• A Nobel Prize-winning physicist explains how to use AI without letting it do your thinking for you
• AI is giving workers the illusion of expertise — and quietly making them worse at their jobs
• Satya Nadella says he spends his weekends studying startups as Microsoft's size has become a 'massive disadvantage'
• 'Think big': A 35-year finance veteran urges Gen Z to start their own businesses as entry-level jobs dry up
• AI is reshaping the teenage brain — and an Oxford study says it is making students faster, but shallower thinkers
• Switching jobs used to mean higher pay raises. Not anymore.
• Canadians were urged to boycott travel to the US in response to tariffs — and numbers suggest they listened

Kelsey is a senior reporter for Business Insider, where she covers business and tech news as well as stories about travel, luxury, and consulting.Her feature story "Disaster at 18,200 feet" received awards from the New York Press Club and the North American Travel Journalists Association, as well as honorable mention from the Society of American Travel Writers. It was also included on Longreads' and Pocket's best of 2022 lists. She has also received an American Journalism Online Award for her coverage on missing and murdered Indigenous people in Wyoming.She's appeared on CBS, NPR, NBC, and other outlets to discuss her work. She previously worked on the world news desk at the BBC in London and received a master's in journalism from Northwestern University.She can be reached by email at [email protected] or via the encrypted-messaging app Signal @kelseyv.21.Popular storiesDisaster on Denali: Inside a 1,000-foot fall on America's highest peakThrifting is more popular than ever. It's also never been worse.Rolex wouldn't service the vintage watch my mom inherited. Watchmakers say it happens all the time.A tiny, invasive bug and the climate crisis are changing how guitars are made, and shifting the course of music historyThe tourism free-for-all is overGovernment-run boarding schools were founded to 'civilize' Native Americans. Hundreds of dead children remain buried in the schoolyard graves.Meet the Texas minister who helps fly dozens of women to New Mexico every month to get abortionsPeople are flocking to Colorado for the great outdoors, but the air pollution is so bad, it's forcing many to stay insideInside Kabul: An aid worker reveals the devastating chaos that erupted during the US exit from Afghanistan